Assisted Suicide: Hemlock's Twisted Logic
by Richard M. DoerflingerOn June 16 the Catholic bishops of the United States approved their first-ever policy statement focused on physician-assisted suicide, To Live Each Day with Dignity. This prompted a response from the group formerly known as the Hemlock Society, which now goes by the euphemism “Compassion & Choices” (C&C).
The title of C&C president Barbara Coombs Lee’s blog, “Dogma vs. Dignity,” nicely sums up her argument: Assisted suicide (though she refuses to call it that) has proved that it serves the freedom and dignity of seriously ill patients in Oregon; C&C promotes “comprehensive palliative care” that includes this option; and the only remaining objection is religious dogma, illustrated by the bishops’ insistence that “one religious authority” can “overrule the most personal decisions of individuals of every faith.”



In November 2009, the U.S. bishops issued the fifth edition of their